Retail space for sale in Coney Island
Coney Island's best-known commercial strip is Surf Avenue by the amusement parks and the boardwalk, where the Shore Theater, a seven-story theater and office building from 1925, stands at Stillwell Avenue by the terminal where the D, F, N and Q lines end. Mermaid and Neptune Avenues carry the everyday stores. The larger buildings sit north of the amusement district: self-storage buildings and big-box stores along Neptune Avenue, Cropsey Avenue and Shell Road toward Coney Island Creek, and a seven-story office and retail building from 2016 on Sheepshead Bay Road near the West 8th Street station.
- Retail stock
- 1.2M SF
- Retail properties
- 169
- Largest retail
- 2970 Cropsey Avenue
- Transit
- D F N Q at Coney Island-Stillwell Av
Building figures are existing stock from NYC PLUTO 26v2 tax lot records, not space on the market. More below.
On Leasemark No retail space for sale and no requirements posted in Coney Island yet. Post yours and it is matched the day it goes up.
Nothing listed here yet
New retail spaces in Coney Island are matched to requirements the day they are posted. Post yours and be first in line.
For owners and brokers
Hear the moment a buyer looks for retail space in Coney Island
Tenant alerts send a notification when a requirement that fits your neighborhood, types and sizes is posted, before you list anything. Real requirements only. Free during Broker Pro early access.
NYC Department of Finance filings
Income and expenses per square foot: retail buildings in Brooklyn
In 2024, 2,856 Brooklyn retail properties filed income statements with the city. Their median gross income was $33.16 per square foot, and the middle half collected between $22.30 and $48.57. Their median operating expense was $7.15 per square foot. The typical property's income was up 1.7% on 2023. The city publishes these figures by borough, not by neighborhood, so they cover Brooklyn as a whole.
Gross income per square foot, 2024
Brooklyn retail buildings
- Median gross income
- $33.16/SF
- Middle half
- $22.30 to $48.57
- Median operating expense
- $7.15/SF
- Typical change on 2023
- +1.68%
- Citywide median
- $36.07/SF
- Filings
- 2,856
Source: NYC Department of Finance, FY 2027 RPIE 2024 Income and Expense Distributions (FY 2027 assessment roll, published January 2026), page 16. Owners of income-producing properties file a Real Property Income and Expense statement each year; gross income is everything a property collected in 2024 per square foot, as filed, with outlier and partial-year filers left out. It includes vacant space, concessions and older leases, so it is not an asking rent.
NYC tax lot records
Retail buildings in Coney Island
What already stands here, from the city's own property data. Useful for sizing a search before a single space is listed.
- Retail space
- 1.2M SF
- Properties with retail space
- 169
- All commercial space
- 3.9M SF
- Built before 1940
- 61%
Largest retail buildings
All 12 large commercial buildings in Coney IslandAge, height and zoning
- Median year built: 1932.
- Median height: 2 floors.
- Most common zoning districts: M1-2 (97), R6 (75), C7 (41). 33% of these lots are zoned for manufacturing.
- 6 lots are designated city landmarks.
Source: NYC Department of City Planning, PLUTO 26v2, pulled 2026-10-16. Counts cover tax lots with commercial floor area within about 0.5 mi of Coney Island's commercial core, and each lot counts toward one neighborhood only, so boundaries are approximate. Building figures are the city's floor-area estimates, not available space.
MTA station data
Subway stations in Coney Island
Every station within about 0.5 mi of Coney Island's commercial core, closest first. Stations joined by a free transfer count once.
- Stations
- 2
- Subway lines
- 4
- Fully accessible
- 1 of 2
- Closest
- Coney Island-Stillwell Av, 2 min walk
The 2 stations
- Coney Island-Stillwell Av
- W 8 St-NY Aquarium
Lines
The D, F, N and Q trains stop within about 0.5 mi of Coney Island's core.
Step-free access
- Coney Island-Stillwell Av (D F N Q) is fully accessible.
Source: Metropolitan Transportation Authority, MTA Subway Stations, pulled 2026-10-16. Walking times are straight-line estimates from the nearest point of Coney Island's commercial core (the same area as the building counts), so the street route is longer. Accessibility is the MTA's rating for the named station. PATH, LIRR, Metro-North and ferries are not in this data.
NYC property records (ACRIS)
Recent retail building sales in Coney Island
One sale of the large retail buildings Leasemark tracks in Coney Island has been recorded since 2016, $18.3 million in all.
Newest sales
Since 2016
- Largest: 1509 Hart Place, $18.3 million in June 2020.
- Newest deed on record: June 2020. The city's open data runs about a month behind.
Source: NYC Department of Finance, ACRIS, Real Property Master, Legals and Parties, pulled 2026-10-16; prices as the deeds state them, buyers named only when they are companies. These are sales of the large buildings Leasemark tracks, not every sale here: condo buildings (sold unit by unit), partial interests and sales of the company that owns a building are left out.
Before you sign
Plain-English guides to square footage, rent and lease terms in New York, and free calculators to run your own numbers.
Buying a commercial condo in NYC: what to check
What to check before you buy an office, retail or medical condo in NYC: the condo documents, permitted use, Local Law 97, carrying costs, closing taxes and financing.
Local Law 97 explained: limits, fines and the 2030 deadline
How NYC's Local Law 97 works: which buildings are covered, the limits through 2049, the $268 a ton penalty and what owners, tenants and buyers should check.
NYC commercial property tax: Class 4 rate, phase-in and appeals
How NYC taxes commercial buildings: Class 4 market value, the 45% assessment, the five-year phase-in, exemptions and PILOTs, bills, and appeals due March 1.
- Free calculator
NYC transfer tax calculator
The city and state transfer taxes on a commercial sale, what the seller keeps and the buyer's mortgage recording tax.
- Free calculator
Mortgage recording tax calculator
The city and state tax on a commercial loan in New York City, part by part, and what a CEMA saves.
Questions about retail space in Coney Island
Is there retail space for sale in Coney Island right now?
No retail space for sale in Coney Island is listed on Leasemark right now. Post what you want to buy and Leasemark matches you the day a space that fits is listed; your contact details stay private until you accept an intro. Owners and brokers can list a space here for free.
How much does retail space cost in Coney Island?
Leasemark has no asking prices posted here yet, so here are the city's own numbers. Owners of retail buildings in Brooklyn reported a median $33.16 of gross income and $7.15 of operating expense per square foot for 2024 (middle half of income: $22.30 to $48.57), according to the income and expense statements owners file with the NYC Department of Finance (FY 2027 distributions, 2,856 filings). The city publishes these figures by borough, so this is Brooklyn as a whole, not Coney Island alone. That is what buildings actually collected, with vacant space, concessions and leases signed years ago in the mix, so it is a baseline rather than a quote: a specific space's price depends on the building's class, floor, condition and the length of the lease.
How do I find retail space in Coney Island that is not publicly listed?
Post a requirement on Leasemark. Owners and listing brokers see what you need (without your contact details) and can respond with spaces, including ones that are not on the market yet. You choose who gets an intro.
How much retail space is there in Coney Island?
New York City's PLUTO tax lot data (26v2) records about 1.2 million square feet of retail floor area across 169 properties in the part of Coney Island Leasemark covers. The largest by that measure is 2970 Cropsey Avenue, at about 149,000 square feet. That is the existing building stock, not space currently for sale.
What subway lines serve Coney Island?
Two subway stations sit within about 0.5 mi of Coney Island's commercial core, served by the D, F, N and Q trains. The closest is Coney Island-Stillwell Av (D F N Q), roughly 2 minutes on foot; then W 8 St-NY Aquarium (F Q). Walking times are straight-line estimates from MTA station data.
Is it free to post on Leasemark?
Yes. Posting a space or a requirement is free. Contact details are only shared when both sides accept an intro.